Year-End Shareholder Compensation: Salary, Dividends and Other Ways to Take Money From Your Corporation

As year-end approaches, one of the questions I discuss with incorporated business owners is:

"How should I take money out of my corporation?"

There isn't one answer that works for every shareholder.

Depending on your situation, you may have several options:

  • Repaying a shareholder loan

  • Paying a capital dividend

  • Returning paid-up capital

  • Paying a taxable dividend

  • Paying a salary or bonus

  • Or using a combination of these

The important part is understanding that these options do not all have the same tax consequences.

There is also an order in which I like to look at the available options.

The goal is not simply to find the lowest tax rate.

It is to determine whether there is money that can be taken out of the corporation using an existing tax attribute before creating a new personal tax liability.

1. Repay a shareholder loan

This is usually the first place I look.

But there are two very different situations that are often called a "shareholder loan."

The corporation owes you money

Suppose you personally paid $20,000 of corporate expenses.

The corporation recorded those expenses, but instead of reimbursing you immediately, it recorded a:

Due to Shareholder — $20,000

The corporation owes you the money.

If the corporation subsequently pays you the $20,000, that is generally a repayment of money the corporation already owed you.

It is not a salary or dividend simply because cash is being transferred to you.

The same concept can apply when you have actually advanced money to the corporation.

The shareholder owes the corporation money

This is completely different.

If you took money out of the corporation and the corporation has recorded a:

Due from Shareholder

you need to be careful.

A shareholder loan or debt from a corporation can be included in the shareholder's income under subsection 15(2) unless a specific exception applies. There are also rules concerning repayment and whether a repayment is part of a series of loans or other transactions.

So don't assume that simply repaying a shareholder loan at year-end makes the original withdrawal tax-free.

The nature and history of the loan matter.

For year-end planning, I first want to know:

Who owes whom?

That can completely change the tax treatment.

2. Consider a capital dividend

If your corporation has a positive Capital Dividend Account (CDA) balance, a capital dividend may be another way to extract funds without personal income tax on the dividend.

Capital dividends are different from ordinary taxable dividends.

A properly designated capital dividend can generally be received tax-free by a Canadian-resident shareholder.

But there is an important catch.

You cannot simply write yourself a cheque and call it a capital dividend.

The corporation needs to have sufficient CDA, the dividend needs to be properly designated, and the required election needs to be filed with the CRA.

This is an area where I would strongly recommend calculating the CDA before the dividend is paid.

An incorrect capital dividend election can create an unexpected tax liability.

3. Return paid-up capital

Another possibility is a return of paid-up capital (PUC).

Very simply, PUC represents the amount of share capital that can potentially be returned to shareholders under the applicable tax rules.

For many small corporations, the amount may be relatively small.

For example, a corporation may have been incorporated with $100 or $1,000 of share capital.

But that is not always the case.

A corporation can have substantially more PUC depending on its history and transactions.

The important point is that returning PUC is not automatically the same thing as paying a regular dividend.

There are specific rules governing reductions of PUC, and a reduction can result in a deemed dividend to the extent that the amount distributed exceeds the relevant PUC.

So before returning capital, I would confirm the corporation's actual PUC rather than relying on what the shareholder remembers investing.

4. Look at the corporation's RDTOH balance

This is where year-end planning can become particularly valuable.

A private corporation may have Refundable Dividend Tax on Hand (RDTOH) as a result of certain types of corporate income, including investment income.

The corporation may be able to recover some of that refundable tax when it pays taxable dividends.

The refund is generally limited to the lesser of the applicable dividend-refund calculation and the corporation's relevant RDTOH balance. The rate used in the refund calculation is 38⅓%.

But there is an important distinction between:

ERDTOH — Eligible RDTOH

and

NERDTOH — Non-eligible RDTOH

This is why simply saying "pay a dividend and get 38.33% back" is incomplete.

The type of RDTOH matters.

5. Non-eligible dividends can recover NERDTOH

If your corporation has NERDTOH generated from investment income, a non-eligible dividend can generally generate a dividend refund, subject to the available balance and the detailed rules.

For example, suppose a corporation has:

$38,333 of NERDTOH

If it pays sufficient qualifying non-eligible dividends, the dividend-refund calculation can potentially recover that amount, subject to the applicable limitations.

The refund calculation is based on 38⅓% of taxable dividends paid, but the corporation cannot receive more than the relevant RDTOH balance.

This is why RDTOH should be reviewed before deciding how much dividend to declare.

6. Eligible dividends are a different calculation

Eligible dividends can also generate a dividend refund, but the rules are tied to the corporation's ERDTOH balance.

This is an important distinction.

If the corporation's refundable tax came from passive investment income and is sitting in NERDTOH, you cannot simply assume that paying an eligible dividend will produce the same refund.

The RDTOH accounts need to be reviewed.

CRA's dividend-refund rules specifically distinguish between eligible RDTOH and non-eligible RDTOH when calculating the refund.

That is why I would not use a blanket rule such as:

"Always pay eligible dividends first."

The corporation's tax attributes need to be looked at first.

7. Consider a salary or bonus

Salary is another way to compensate an owner-manager.

Unlike a dividend, salary is generally deductible to the corporation when it meets the requirements for deductibility.

The shareholder reports the salary as employment income.

Salary can also create RRSP contribution room and may have CPP implications.

That makes salary fundamentally different from dividends.

For example, a shareholder may prefer salary because they want to create additional RRSP contribution room.

Another shareholder may prefer dividends because they do not need additional employment income.

The right answer depends on the shareholder's overall tax and financial situation.

Salary versus dividends isn't just about the tax rate

It is tempting to ask:

"Which is better — salary or dividends?"

But that question is too broad.

You need to consider:

  • Corporate tax

  • Personal income tax

  • CPP

  • RRSP contribution room

  • Available corporate tax attributes

  • RDTOH

  • CDA

  • The corporation's cash position

  • Other personal income

  • The shareholder's financial needs

The lowest current-year personal tax is not necessarily the only objective.

For some business owners, creating RRSP room through salary is valuable.

For others, a dividend may make more sense.

And in some situations, using a combination can be appropriate.

The year-end review I would do

When I review shareholder compensation at year-end, I would not start by asking:

"How much money do you want to take out?"

I would start with the corporation's tax attributes.

Step 1 — Is the corporation owing the shareholder money?

Check the shareholder loan or due-to-shareholder balance.

If the corporation owes the shareholder money, repayment may be the simplest place to start.

Step 2 — Is there a CDA balance?

If there is a positive CDA balance, determine whether a capital dividend can be paid.

Step 3 — What is the PUC?

If the corporation has meaningful paid-up capital, determine whether a return of capital is available and what the tax consequences would be.

Step 4 — What are the RDTOH balances?

Determine whether the corporation has:

  • ERDTOH

  • NERDTOH

and whether paying a dividend could generate a refund.

Step 5 — What type of dividend makes sense?

If a taxable dividend is being considered, determine whether it should be designated as eligible or non-eligible based on the corporation's tax attributes and the shareholder's circumstances.

Step 6 — Should salary or a bonus be considered?

Finally, compare the dividend option with salary or a bonus, including CPP and RRSP considerations.

A simple example

Imagine an Ontario CCPC has accumulated cash and the owner wants to withdraw $100,000 before year-end.

It would be a mistake to immediately record:

Dividend — $100,000

without first reviewing the corporation.

Suppose the corporation has:

  • $15,000 due to the shareholder

  • $10,000 of available CDA

  • $5,000 of available PUC

  • $20,000 of NERDTOH

  • Additional cash available for compensation

The tax planning conversation becomes very different.

There may be several tax attributes available before simply creating a new taxable dividend.

The actual calculation would need to consider the corporation's records, tax balances, prior transactions and the shareholder's personal tax position.

The point is that the corporation's tax attributes should be reviewed before deciding how to extract the cash.

Don't treat this as a fixed seven-step formula

The order above is a useful planning framework, not a mandatory CRA sequence.

There are circumstances where salary may make more sense than a dividend.

There may be no CDA.

There may be no meaningful PUC.

The corporation may not have RDTOH.

There may be shareholder-loan issues that need to be dealt with first.

And the shareholder may have other personal income that changes the result.

This is why year-end compensation should be planned rather than simply entered into the books after the year is over.

What about the 38.33% dividend refund?

You will often hear:

"The corporation gets 38.33% back when it pays a dividend."

That is an oversimplification.

The dividend refund is subject to the corporation's RDTOH balances and the type of dividend paid.

CRA calculates the refund using the applicable RDTOH accounts and the 38⅓% rate, subject to the relevant limitations.

So if your corporation has RDTOH, the first question should not be:

"How much dividend should I pay?"

It should be:

"What type of RDTOH does the corporation have, and what dividend would actually generate the refund?"

That is a much more useful question.

And don't forget personal tax

Even when the corporation receives a dividend refund, that does not mean the shareholder receives the dividend tax-free.

The shareholder generally has personal tax consequences from receiving a taxable dividend.

The actual tax depends on the type of dividend, the shareholder's other income and their province of residence.

For an Ontario resident in 2026, the combined federal and Ontario personal tax rates are progressive, with the highest ordinary income rates and dividend tax rates depending on the type of income and applicable credits. CRA's 2026 tables show the federal and Ontario brackets separately.

This is why I would avoid relying on a statement such as:

"Eligible dividends cost 38% and non-eligible dividends cost 48%."

Those numbers can be useful as rough illustrations at certain income levels, but they are not universal tax rates.

The real objective

The goal of year-end shareholder compensation isn't necessarily to minimize the amount of tax paid this year at all costs.

The goal is to make sure you are using the corporation's available tax attributes efficiently while considering your personal and business needs.

That may mean:

Repay what the corporation already owes you.

Then consider whether there is:

CDA available for a capital dividend.

Then review:

PUC and other corporate tax attributes.

Then consider:

RDTOH and taxable dividends.

And finally compare:

Salary, bonus and dividends based on your overall situation.

The exact order can change depending on the corporation.

Final thoughts

Year-end is more than just closing the books and filing the T2.

For owner-managed corporations, it is also an opportunity to review how money should be extracted from the corporation.

Before simply declaring a dividend or paying a bonus, look at what the corporation already has available.

A shareholder loan payable to you may be repaid.

A positive CDA may allow for a capital dividend.

Paid-up capital may provide another avenue in the right circumstances.

RDTOH may allow the corporation to recover refundable tax when qualifying taxable dividends are paid.

And salary or a bonus may make sense depending on your personal tax position, CPP and RRSP objectives.

There is no universal "best" method.

The right approach depends on the corporation's tax attributes, the owner's personal circumstances and how much cash the business actually needs.

Before year-end, review the numbers first. Then decide how to take the money out.

Ready to better understand your business finances?

Next
Next

Meals and Entertainment Expenses: When Can a Business Deduct 100%?